Undertow · Chapter 2
The First Save
Rescue under the tide
26 min readJames's first rescue at eighteen -- a girl in a rip at Stand 2, save number one, the moment the notebook began.
James's first rescue at eighteen -- a girl in a rip at Stand 2, save number one, the moment the notebook began.
Undertow
Chapter 2: The First Save
The girl was nine years old and she was drowning at two-seventeen in the afternoon on June 28, 2005, in four feet of water that was moving at three feet per second in the seaward direction, which meant the water was not four feet anymore, which meant the four feet was already five and the five was becoming six and the six was becoming the depth at which a nine-year-old girl could not touch the bottom and the not-touching was the beginning, was the first sentence of the drowning, the sentence that the girl did not know she was writing because the writing was not voluntary, was not a choice, was the ocean's authorship imposed on the body that had entered it with the confidence of a child who believed the water was a toy, a plaything, a thing that existed for the purpose of fun and that the fun was guaranteed and the guarantee was the summer and the summer was the beach and the beach was the place where nothing bad happened because the beach was where you came to play.
James was eighteen years old. He had been on the Asbury Park Beach Patrol for twenty-three days. He had been assigned to Stand 2, two hundred yards south of the jetty, the second position, the junior position, the stand where rookies learned the beach the way a medical student learned the hospital -- by being present, by watching, by absorbing through proximity the accumulated knowledge of a system that could not be fully transmitted by instruction, that had to be experienced, inhabited, lived in before it could be understood, the way you lived in the water before you understood the water, the way you lived in the language before you spoke the language.
He was alone on the stand. His senior partner, a fourth-year guard named Vincenzo, had rotated off the platform fifteen minutes earlier for the standard break -- thirty minutes, the contractual rest that the patrol's operational guidelines required every ninety minutes of stand time, the thirty minutes during which the rookie was alone, during which the rookie was the guard, during which the rookie's eyes were the only eyes and the rookie's judgment was the only judgment and the difference between the rookie and the veteran was erased by the fact of the responsibility, because the responsibility did not know about experience, did not care about tenure, did not adjust itself to the number of days the person on the stand had been on the stand. The responsibility was the same on day twenty-three as it was on day twenty-three hundred. The water did not check the rookie's resume.
The conditions were moderate. Two-foot swell, onshore wind from the southeast at eight knots, incoming tide. Green flag. The beach was crowded -- a Tuesday in late June, the first week of full summer, the week when the schools let out and the families arrived and the beach transitioned from the May and early June lull to the density that would build through July and peak on the Fourth and sustain through August before the thinning that September brought. James estimated four hundred people on the sand. Fifty in the water. The fifty were distributed across the swimming area in the uneven pattern that swimmers produced when they entered the ocean without a plan, the distribution that was partly random and partly determined by the currents and the sandbars and the social physics of humans near other humans -- families clustering, teenagers grouping, the solitary swimmers finding the open water, the body-surfers seeking the break, each person occupying the position the ocean's topography and the person's intention had negotiated between them.
James scanned. The scanning was the thing he had been taught to do and the thing he was learning to do, and the teaching and the learning were different, because the teaching was the protocol -- left to right, right to left, near to far, every thirty seconds, the systematic visual coverage of every square yard of the swimming area -- and the learning was the perception, the development of the eyes' ability to detect the thing that did not belong within the pattern, the anomaly that was the drowning, and the anomaly was subtle, was not the thrashing and the screaming that the movies depicted but the quiet, the terribly quiet signal of a body that was losing its contest with the water and that was losing it silently, because the drowning used the lungs for breathing and not for screaming and the breathing was the priority and the screaming was the luxury and the drowning could not afford the luxury.
He had been taught the signs. Captain Stern had taught them in the pre-season training course, ten days in May, eight hours a day, the classroom sessions and the pool sessions and the beach sessions that together comprised the education of a new lifeguard, the education that was preparation for the thing the education could not fully prepare you for, because the thing itself was different from the training for the thing, the way a fire was different from the fire drill, the way a drowning was different from the simulated drowning in the pool where the instructor played the victim and the victim knew he was not drowning and the rescuer knew the victim knew and the knowing was the safety net and the safety net was the thing the ocean did not provide.
The signs: a head low in the water, mouth at the waterline. Arms at the sides, pressing down. No kick. The body vertical, not horizontal. The hair over the eyes and forehead. No call for help. The head tilting back. The eyes wide but not focused, glassy, looking at something that was not the shore, not the stand, not the guard, but at the inside of the drowning itself, the interior landscape of the body losing its argument with gravity and water and the physics that said: a body that is not buoyant will sink, and a body that has exhausted its capacity to keep itself buoyant has become a body that is not buoyant, and the becoming is the drowning, and the drowning is the thing the guard is on the stand to see.
He saw it at two-seventeen. He saw the girl's head. He saw the head go low. He saw the arms, which had been splashing -- the girl had been playing in the water with another child, the two of them jumping through the small waves near the sandbar, the play that was the joy that was the summer that was the thing the beach existed to provide -- and the arms stopped splashing and started pressing, pushing down on the water's surface as if the surface were a table and the pushing could make the table hold her weight, and the pushing was the sign, the unmistakable sign, the sign that James had been taught to see and that he was now seeing, for the first time, in a body that was not an instructor in a pool but a girl in the ocean, and the difference between the instructor and the girl was the difference between the drill and the fire, and the fire was now.
He came off the stand in three seconds. The coming-off was an action he had practiced in training -- the dismount, the rapid descent from the platform to the sand, the movement that began in the legs and flowed through the torso and ended with the feet hitting the sand and the body already moving forward, already running, the transition from sitting to sprinting that was supposed to happen without thought, without decision, without the intervening cognitive step of should-I-go, because the should was settled, had been settled before the guard climbed the stand, settled by the putting on of the suit and the climbing of the steps and the sitting in the chair, the sequence of actions that said: I am here, I am watching, and if the watching finds the thing, I will go.
He grabbed the rescue can from the hook on the stand's support post. The can was red, torpedo-shaped, hard-shelled, and the strap went over his right shoulder and across his chest and the towline trailed behind him as he ran. He ran across the sand. The sand was hot and soft and deep where the beach sloped upward from the waterline, the dry sand that resisted the running, that slowed the feet, that took the energy of each step and absorbed it the way a sponge absorbed water, returning nothing, giving no push, no spring, no assist, the sand that was the first obstacle between the guard on the stand and the person in the water, the obstacle that the training runs were meant to condition the body for, the dawn runs on the beach that Captain Stern required every morning before the stands opened, the six-thirty runs in the cool sand with the other guards, the running that was not exercise but rehearsal, the rehearsal for this, for the run across the sand that meant someone was drowning.
The distance was seventy yards. Seventy yards of sand from the base of Stand 2 to the waterline. James covered it in approximately fourteen seconds, which he would not remember and which no one timed but which he would reconstruct later, in the notebook, by counting his steps and estimating his pace, because the reconstruction was the thing, the accounting, the attempt to make the chaotic overwhelming sensory flood of the first rescue into a narrative with numbers and facts and a sequence that could be reviewed and assessed and learned from, the way a pilot reviewed a flight, the way a surgeon reviewed a procedure, the professional debrief that turned the experience into the education.
He hit the water. The water was sixty-six degrees and the sixty-six degrees hit his ankles and his shins and his thighs as he ran through the shallows, the depth increasing with each stride, the water resisting his legs with increasing force as the depth increased, the resistance that was the water's indifference to his urgency, the water not caring that he was running toward a drowning girl, the water applying the same hydrodynamic drag to the rescuer as it applied to the victim, because the water did not know the difference, did not distinguish between the person who was drowning and the person who was trying to prevent the drowning, the water treating all bodies the same, with the democratic indifference of a force that recognized mass and velocity and nothing else.
At waist depth he dove. The dive was the transition from running to swimming, the moment the body shifted from terrestrial to aquatic locomotion, from the upright bipedal stride that humans had evolved for the land to the horizontal undulating crawl that humans had learned for the water, the learned motion that was not instinct but training, not nature but cultivation, the swimming that his mother had taught him in the ocean at Belmar when he was four years old, the swimming that she had given him the way she had given him language, by immersion, by daily practice, by the patient repetitive exposure of the body to the medium until the medium became the body's second home, until the water that was foreign became the water that was familiar, until the boy who could not swim became the boy who could, and the could was the inheritance, the maternal inheritance that was now carrying him toward a girl who was drowning because she had not received that inheritance, because the water was not her home, because the water was the foreign place that had become the dangerous place and the dangerous was becoming the fatal and the fatal was what James was swimming to prevent.
He swam. The stroke was a crawl, the competitive crawl he had refined on the Asbury Park High School swim team, the stroke that was not the most energy-efficient but that was the fastest, the stroke that covered distance at the maximum rate, because the distance was the enemy and the time was the currency and the currency was depleting with every second the girl's head was at the waterline and the arms were pressing and the drowning was progressing from the early stage to the active stage and from the active stage toward the submersion, the going-under from which the rescue became recovery and the recovery was the thing that was not rescue, the thing that was the opposite of rescue, the thing that was the finding of a body that was no longer a person but was now a body, and the body was the thing the scanning existed to prevent, the thing the running and the swimming and the rescue can and the eighteen years of James Calloway's life had been assembled to prevent.
The rip had her. He could feel it as he swam across its edge -- the lateral pull, the sideways tug that said the water here was organized, was flowing, was moving seaward with a coherence and a force that the disorganized water around it did not have. The rip was not wide. Perhaps thirty feet. But the girl was in it, in the center of the channel where the current was strongest, and the current was carrying her past the sandbar into the deeper water and the deeper water was the problem because the deeper water was deeper and the deeper was the distance from the surface and the distance from the surface was the distance from the air and the air was the thing the girl needed and the needing was the drowning.
He reached her. The reaching was the moment -- the moment when the swimming stopped being forward motion and became something else, became the encounter, the physical meeting of the rescuer and the victim, the two bodies in the water, the one that was swimming and the one that was sinking and the rescue can between them, the red plastic intermediary that the training said to put between yourself and the victim, always the can first, because the victim would grab and the grabbing was not controlled, was not rational, was the animal reflex of a body seeking the solid, seeking the thing that floated, seeking the buoyancy that the body had lost, and the grabbing could pull the rescuer under if the rescuer was the thing grabbed, and the rescuer going under was two drownings instead of one, and two drownings was the thing the can existed to prevent.
He pushed the can toward her. He said words. He did not remember the words later, could not reconstruct them in the notebook, could not retrieve them from the noise and the water and the adrenaline and the overwhelming sensory overload of the first time, the first rescue, the first real encounter with the thing the training had simulated and the simulation had approximated and the approximation had failed to capture, because the simulation could not capture the eyes. The girl's eyes. The eyes that looked at him from the waterline, from the surface of the water that was at the level of her mouth, and the eyes were not the instructor's eyes in the pool, were not the eyes of a person who knew they were not drowning, were the eyes of a girl who was nine years old and who was drowning and who saw him and whose seeing was the thing, the look that said: I am here, I am in the water, the water is taking me, and you are here, and are you the thing between me and the taking.
She grabbed the can. She grabbed it with both hands and the grabbing was the thing the training had described -- the clutch, the grip, the desperate acquisition of the floating thing by the sinking thing, the hands that locked onto the red plastic with a force that exceeded the girl's size, that was not the force of a nine-year-old girl but the force of a body that was choosing life over death and that was channeling the choice through the hands, through the fingers, through the white-knuckled grip that said: I will not let go of this, I will not release this thing that floats, this thing that holds me above the surface, this red thing that the boy brought, this thing between me and the under.
He swam her to shore. He swam sidestroke, the rescue stroke, the stroke the training had specified for towing -- the side position that kept the rescuer's face above water and the towline extended and the victim behind and to the side, the geometry of the tow that maintained the distance between the rescuer and the victim while keeping the victim connected to the can and the can connected to the line and the line connected to the rescuer and the whole chain of connection moving shoreward, moving toward the sand, moving toward the place where the water ended and the land began and the land was the safety and the safety was the thing the swimming was for.
The rip fought him. The current pulled seaward and he swam shoreward and the contest was the swim, the physical negotiation between the body's power and the water's power, the negotiation that the training had prepared him for but that the training had conducted in a pool and the pool did not have a rip current and the rip current was the opponent and the opponent was strong and the strong was the thing that made the swimming hard, harder than the training swims, harder than the six-thirty morning runs in the surf, harder than anything his body had done because the body was now doing the thing under the conditions the thing was meant to be done under and the conditions were the ocean and the ocean did not cooperate.
He angled across the rip. He did not swim directly against it -- even at eighteen, even on his first rescue, he knew the principle: swim perpendicular to the current, escape the channel, find the water that was not moving seaward, find the still water, the slack water, the water that would let you swim shoreward without the opposition of the rip. He angled south-southeast, across the current's flow, and the current released them -- not released, because the current did not hold and therefore could not release, but the current's influence diminished as they crossed its boundary, as they moved from the organized flow of the channel into the disorganized water of the surrounding ocean, the water that was not ripping but merely waving, merely doing the normal thing, the shoreward push and the seaward pull that was the ocean's breathing, the inhalation and the exhalation that was not dangerous but was normal, was the baseline, was the ocean at its quotidian work.
He felt the sand under his feet. He felt it with his toes and then with his soles and the feeling was the arrival, the coming back to the land from the water, the return that was the rescue's conclusion, the feet-on-sand that said: you made it, you swam out and you reached her and you put the can in her hands and you swam her back and now the sand is under your feet and the sand is the solid and the solid is the shore and the shore is where the drowning ends.
He stood. The water was waist-deep. He pulled the towline and the girl came toward him, still gripping the can, and he took her under the arms and he lifted her -- she was light, sixty pounds, the weight of a nine-year-old girl who had been in the ocean and who was now coming out of the ocean, the weight that was not heavy, that was nothing compared to the weight of the water he had swum through, compared to the weight of the current he had crossed, compared to the weight that was not physical but that was settling on him now, in the waist-deep water, with the girl in his arms, the weight that he would carry for the rest of his career, the weight that was the knowledge, the understanding, the recognition that he had just done the thing, that the training was not the thing but that this was the thing, that the thing was real and the thing was heavy and the thing was his.
He carried her to the sand. He set her down on the wet sand at the waterline. She was coughing. She was breathing. The coughing was the breathing and the breathing was the living and the living was the thing, the thing the rescue had produced, the outcome that was the only acceptable outcome, the outcome that justified the stand and the scanning and the running and the swimming and the can and the eighteen years of life that had brought James Calloway to this piece of sand on this afternoon to do this thing for this girl.
The mother came. The mother ran across the beach from wherever the mother had been -- from the towel, from the blanket, from the spot on the sand where the mother had been sitting when the daughter entered the water and the sitting was not negligence, was not failure, was the ordinary parental inattention of a person at the beach on a Tuesday in June who had looked away for the number of seconds the ocean needed to begin its work, and the seconds were not many, and the looking away was not long, and the ocean's work was fast, and the fast was the thing, the speed of the drowning that exceeded the speed of the parental attention, and the exceeding was the gap, and in the gap the guard was meant to be, and the guard had been, and the guard had seen the thing the mother had not seen and had done the thing the mother could not do.
The mother's face did the thing. James watched the mother's face do the thing that faces did when the worst thing almost happened and then did not happen, the thing that was not one expression but a sequence of expressions compressed into a single moment -- the terror and the relief and the gratitude and the guilt and the love, the whole emotional cascade that a face could not contain but that the face attempted to contain, the attempt that was the failing, the failing that was the crumpling, the crumpling that was the tears, the tears that were the mother's response to the fact that her daughter was alive and coughing and sitting on the sand and the sitting and the coughing and the being-alive were the miracle, and the miracle was the boy in the red suit who was standing beside her daughter on the wet sand with a rescue can over his shoulder and salt water running from his hair down his face and the particular expression of a person who has just done the thing for the first time, the first-time face, the face that does not yet know what the face will come to know, which is that the thing will be done again and again, 213 more times, and each time will be the same and each time will be different and each time will be the thing, the entering of the water and the finding of the person and the bringing of the person back to the sand.
The mother said thank you. The mother said it and the saying was the thing people said, the words that were the words, the conventional response to the unconventional event, the two words that were supposed to contain the gratitude and that could not contain the gratitude the way the word proud could not contain the pride, the way the word ocean could not contain the ocean, the inadequacy of language in the face of the thing language was being asked to describe.
James nodded. He said something. He did not remember what he said. He remembered the nodding. He remembered the standing on the sand with the can over his shoulder and the water running down his face and the girl coughing and the mother kneeling beside the girl and the ocean behind them all, the ocean that had tried to take the girl and that had failed to take the girl because James had entered the ocean and had taken the girl back, and the taking-back was the rescue and the rescue was the thing and the thing was done.
Vincenzo returned from his break. Vincenzo climbed Stand 2 and settled into the chair and looked at James on the sand and at the girl and at the mother and at the rescue can and understood, without being told, what had happened, because the scene was legible, was a text that a fourth-year guard could read the way he read the water -- the wet guard, the coughing child, the kneeling mother, the can with the deployed towline, the specific arrangement of bodies and objects that said: a rescue happened here. Vincenzo looked at James and nodded. The nod said: good. The nod said: you did the thing. The nod said: this is what you're here for.
James climbed the stand. He sat in the chair. He looked at the water. The water was the same water. The water had not changed. The water that had been drowning a girl five minutes ago was doing nothing five minutes later, was merely waving, merely pushing and pulling, merely performing its operations with the indifference of a system that did not know what it had done and that would not know what it did next. The water was the water. The rescue had not changed the water. The rescue had changed James.
He felt the change. He felt it in the hands, which were trembling, the fine tremor that the adrenaline produced as it metabolized, the chemical aftermath of the fight-or-flight response that had powered the running and the swimming and the rescuing and that was now subsiding, leaving in its wake the tremor and the clarity and the specific post-rescue awareness that he would come to know well but that on this first day was new, was unfamiliar, was the body's way of saying: something happened, something real, something that was not training and not simulation and not practice but the thing itself.
He felt it in the chest. Not the lungs -- the lungs were recovering, the breathing normalizing, the respiratory system returning from the extreme demand of the sprint and the swim to the baseline demand of the sitting. The feeling was deeper than the lungs. The feeling was in the sternum, behind the bone, in the place where the body stored the things the body could not name, the things that were not physical but that had physical locations, the things that lived in the architecture of the chest the way a sound lived in the architecture of a room. The feeling was a buzzing. Not a vibration. Not a hum. A buzzing, the particular frequency of a thing that had happened and that the body was still processing, still incorporating, still making room for in the interior space where the body kept its experiences, its memories, its knowledge of what it had done and what it could do and what it would be called upon to do again.
The buzzing would become familiar. The buzzing would become the signal, the body's own alarm, the internal notification that said: the water is doing something, the water is taking someone, the body must go. James would learn to read the buzzing the way he learned to read the water -- by experience, by repetition, by the accumulation of events that taught the body to recognize the thing before the mind named it, the instinct that preceded the thought, the physical knowledge that was faster than the cognitive knowledge, the body knowing what the brain would know a second later.
But on this day, the first day, the buzzing was new and the new was the trembling and the trembling was the hands and the hands were on his knees and the knees were still and the stillness of the knees was the discipline and the discipline was the sitting and the sitting was the returning to the stand and the returning to the stand was the thing, the thing that the first rescue taught, the thing that every subsequent rescue confirmed: you go in, you get them, you bring them back, and then you climb the stand and you sit in the chair and you scan the water and you wait for the next time, because there will be a next time, because the water does not stop, the water does not rest, the water does not observe the rescue as a conclusion but only as an interruption, a brief interruption of its work, and the work continues, and the scanning continues, and the guard continues, and the continuing is the job.
He bought the notebook the next day. He drove to the Staples on Route 35 in Neptune Township and he walked the aisles and he found the composition books on a shelf near the back, the black-and-white marbled covers, the wide-ruled pages, the stitched bindings that would not catch on the locker shelf and would not bend and would not lose their pages. He picked one up. He held it. It weighed almost nothing. The weight of paper and cardboard and thread, the weight of a thing that had not yet been written in, the weight of potential, of the blank pages that were waiting for the entries that would fill them.
He sat in his truck in the Staples parking lot and he opened the notebook to the first page. He uncapped a pen. A blue Bic, the kind that came in ten-packs, the kind that cost less than a dollar and that wrote in the blue ink that was the default ink, the ink of the ordinary, the ink that did not announce itself as special or significant but that was the ink that happened to be in his pocket and that would become, over twenty years, the ink of the record, the specific blue of the saves.
He wrote the first entry.
6/28/05. Stand 2. 2:17 PM. Rip current, south end. F, ~9. Solo rescue, rescue can. Lateral swim across rip, approximately 80 yards. Victim conscious, coughing, ambulatory. Mother present. No EMT transport. Save #1.
He looked at the entry. He looked at the words. The words were small and the thing they described was not small and the gap between the words and the thing was the gap that every record contained, the gap between the experience and the notation, between the living of the thing and the writing of the thing, the gap that was not a failure of the words but a condition of the words, the condition that said: words can note but words cannot hold, words can mark but words cannot contain, and the containing is not the words' job, and the holding is not the words' job, and the words' job is the marking, the noting, the recording that says this happened, on this day, at this time, in this water, and the happening was real and the person was real and the rescue was real and the realness is the thing the words preserve, the thing the words keep, the thing that without the words would be only memory, and memory fades, and the fading is the losing, and the losing is the thing the notebook prevents, the way the rescue prevents the drowning, the way the guard prevents the loss.
Save number one.
He closed the notebook. He put it in the glove compartment. The next day he brought it to the beach. He put it in his locker, on the bottom shelf, behind the board shorts and the zinc oxide and the things that accumulated in a locker over the course of a summer. The notebook lived there. The notebook would live there for twenty years, waiting for the entries, receiving the entries, holding the entries in its stitched pages with the patience of a thing whose only purpose was to hold what was written in it, the way the stand's only purpose was to hold the guard who sat on it, the way the can's only purpose was to hold the person who grabbed it, the way the ocean's only purpose was to be the thing it was, which was the water, which was the medium, which was the thing that made the saving necessary and the saving possible, the thing that drowned and the thing that was swum through to prevent the drowning, the thing that took and the thing that gave, the giving being the resistance that the swimming pushed against, the resistance that was the ocean's only contribution to the rescue, the passive participant, the medium through which the guard moved to reach the person who was sinking in the medium, and the reaching was the thing, and the thing was save number one, and save number one was the beginning.
Reader tools
Save this exact stopping point, open the chapter list, jump to discussion, or quietly report a problem without leaving the page.
Reader tools
Save this exact stopping point, open the chapter list, jump to discussion, or quietly report a problem without leaving the page.
Moderation
Report only when a chapter or surrounding reader surface needs another look. Reports stay private.
Checking account access…
Keep reading
Chapter 3: The Patrol
The next chapter is ready, but Sighing will wait here until you choose to continue. Turn autoplay on if you want a hands-free countdown at the end of future chapters.
Discussion
Comments
Thoughtful replies help the chapter feel alive for the next reader. Keep it specific, generous, and close to the page.
Join the discussion to leave a chapter note, reply to another reader, or like the comments that sharpened the page for you.
Open a first thread
No one has broken the silence on this chapter yet. Sign in if you want to be the first reader to start that thread.
Chapter signal
A quiet aggregate of reads, readers, comments, and finished passes as this chapter moves through the shelf.
Loading signal…